
Adverts from Rips by Triumph and Packed - two popular card-ripping platforms - have come under scrutiny after an investigation found the companies using marketing that suggests collectors could make money to cover food, rent, and other everyday expenses.
The investigation, published on November 3, was carried out by Barron's, a major US financial news publication owned by Dow Jones, which also publishes The Wall Street Journal.
Throughout, Barron's examined adverts from both platforms that appeared to show digital card packs as potential solutions to financial problems - despite the significant risk of losing money.
One Rips advertisement showed a man opening his refrigerator and complaining that he has nothing to eat. He then spends $100 on a digital basketball-card pack, reveals a card worth $119.90, and then pans back to him celebrating that he can afford to order food.
Another advert from Packed showed a woman saying she's broke and needs money to pay the rent, before turning to Pokémon pack openings.
The Odds Tell a Different Story
According to Barron's, the adverts they investigated focused on profitable pulls. However, a closer look at the figures Barron's uncovered shows exactly why these kinds of advertisements are so misleading.
According to the investigation, a typical Rips pack carries around a 50% chance of ripping a card valued below the purchase price. A $100 pack offered by Packed has at least a 70% chance of producing a lower-valued card.
This is, of course, not surprising; it's the way the instant ripping industry works, and there's nothing wrong with it - provided consumers know what they're purchasing, understand the probabilities - and get treated fairly by platforms.
It's when platforms begin claiming opening their packs could be a solution to financial issues that things become problematic.
Online pack-opening sites have started to get far more attention recently, and Barron's investigation highlights exactly why there's growing criticism of the industry.
Instant-rip platforms aren't (yet) subject to the same regulations as online casinos - but regardless of what happens with regulation, the industry does have a responsibility to police itself. That means being transparent about odds, treating customers fairly - and avoiding running ads that encourage people to spend money they can't afford to lose.